Anne Maria Mitchell (1847 – 1929)

Jascin N. Leonardo Finger • September 16, 2024

In the vein of sharing more about other family members, here is a little bit about one of Maria Mitchell’s nieces.


The only child of Maria’s younger brother, William Forster and his wife Charlotte Coffin Dow Mitchell, Annie Maria as she was called – named for two of her aunts – illustrated a keen aptitude for writing at a young age. While still in high school, the island papers printed her stories to high acclaim. In the footsteps of her abolitionist father, Annie Maria would follow him into the South when she was just 18 years of age, working under him as a teacher in Alabama and Tennessee as they worked with formerly enslaved people. Besides teaching, she and her father provided aid to the formerly enslaved through their work with the Freedmen’s Aid Commission. In their work, they would cross paths with numerous other Nantucketers – many, if not all, raised as Quakers.


While she would leave and return North in 1867 at the age of 20, Annie Maria would refocus her efforts on her writing. Her work for those she had taught in the South continued as she wrote several works of fiction including Freed Boy in Alabama and educational primer books for those learning to read. While she would write books for all audiences, several of her early books focused on characters who were Black, perhaps providing examples of strong Black characters at a time when such characters did not exist in literature and thus serving as positive and inspiring representation for Black readers.

In 1871, she married Alfred Rickman Payne, an Englishman. They would have four daughters: Charlotte “Lottie” Payne (b. September 10, 1873, d. Sept 15, 1873), Fanny Ursula Payne, Alice Mary Payne, and Eliza Katherine Payne – named for her great aunt, Eliza Katherine “Kate” Mitchell Dame, who lived in Lynn and was the youngest of William and Lydia Coleman Mitchell’s children (and Maria Mitchell’s youngest sister). With a house full of children, much of her writing and publishing came to an end and she focused on her church. Annie Maria died in Brooklyn, NY at the age of 82.


JNLF


The image is of Anne Maria Mitchell Payne and one of her granddaughters.  The dog’s name has long been forgotten – but what a cutie!

Recent Posts

By Jascin N. Leonardo Finger • September 21, 2026
Sept. 24, 1881. . . . Mr. I. {van Ingen} thinks that not a person on the Board of Trustees would approve of the clause in Mr. Vassar’s will which objected to women as occupants of chairs. Just months before, Maria Mitchell had written a letter describing the controversy surrounding the bequest of Matthew Vassar to the college he founded. The large sum was separated out within his will, including the establishment of department chairs. The bequest for this action, however, did not allow for women professors to have a chair. Quite shocking for a women’s college but then, there were early trustees in the College’s founding who believed that women professors should not exist at Vassar! Maria would be the first professor Vassar hired – male OR female. JNLF
By Jascin N. Leonardo Finger • September 14, 2026
Do you know what these Mitchell House Junior Historians are doing? It is a good old-fashioned round of hoop rolling. And, they had a lot of fun learning how to use them down at the Coffin School one day. Hoop rolling or hoop trundling were popular from very early on and well into the twentieth century. By early on I mean Ancient Greece even. It’s on ancient pottery and was not limited to children! Native Americans, ancient Rome, 16 th century England – it’s been known by different names, taken various formats, played by various ages, and played through various ages. In the nineteenth century, both boys and girls did hoop rolling – and it was likely seen as a more “ladylike” active game that girls could play. I’m assuming that is likely the reason why several women’s colleges still have I tradition of rolling hoops. We use these sometimes in the summer during our weeklong Mitchell House children’s program – Junior Historians. Do not be too surprised if you see me out on the lawn on Vestal Street practicing on warm days this fall, winter, and spring! Got to get up to speed! JNLF
September 1, 2026
“If you don’t look, you don’t see. You have to go and look.” -Edith Andrews
Show More